Skip to main content

It's not you. It's me.

A couple of days ago Read Roger posted his thoughts on the reader's right "not to finish a book."There are many reasons you might choose not to finish a book. You get bogged down, lose interest, something more engaging comes along, you may not even be able to put your finger on the exact reason. But one way or another you put it down and don't come back. 

I am often motivated to finish a book I am not enjoying out of sheer perversity or a desperate hope that it will pull itself out of the nosedive at the last minute. But the last book I simply walked away from? I think that was The Fetch. It was just so cold and strange and, try as I might, I couldn't get close to any of the characters. I don't like doing it, but finally it was just time to move on.

So what was the last book you gave up on? And do you have a hard and fast rule on calling it quits? 

Comments

  1. I started into the first volume of a very popular MG fantasy series, got about five chapters in, and... just couldn't bring myself to go on.

    It wasn't that Action Stuff wasn't happening, it was that I'd never really been captivated by any of the characters (sure, they were nice people, but none of them had that *spark*, you know?) and so it didn't really matter to me if they survived the Action Stuff or not.

    I'm thinking that maybe I just missed something, or read it at the wrong time, and if I force myself to push through to the end, I might get what it is that so many other people like about this series. But on the other hand... I have a pile of other books to read yet, and life is short.

    I think that if I were an agent/editor and that manuscript came across my desk, I would be sending the author back a reply that said, "There's nothing really wrong with it, but I didn't fall in love with it. Best of luck placing this manuscript with another agent/editor."

    As for hard and fast rules, I don't usually give up on books, even ones I'm not enjoying very much -- I'm a speed reader so it's almost easier just to skim through to the end and see if it gets any better. But if I'm five or six chapters in and I'm just not having any fun at all, and there seems to be nothing built up in the story that I can look forward to, then it's time to call it quits.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I love the title of the post.

    ReplyDelete
  3. It is a great title post. I also end up just skimming the book. I have a hard time, specially if I had bought the book to just DNF. I have a friend you also had a hard time finishing The Fetch because it said it had romance, but when she read it it had little or no romance in it. The last book I had a hard time finishing was Death's Daughter by Amber Benson.

    ReplyDelete
  4. RJ, that's it exactly. At least one (preferably two or more) character needs to spark. Otherwise....the void.

    Liz, grin. It's just how I feel when I have to break up with a book I'm reading.

    Princess Allie, I just could not slog through another page of it. I felt bad, too, as I loved the author's first book, which was just beautiful. I've never read anything by Benson.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I really hate not finishing a book I have started, and I try to push through most of the time. Having said that, I have had one DNF this year already which is a bit of a worry, because normally I only have one a year! The book I gave up on a few weeks ago was The Fool's Tale by Nicole Galland.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Marg, one a year's not bad. But I can see why you're a bit nervous. Mine was in January and it was a bit disheartening.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Anonymous8:57 PM

    I kind of get easily impatient if the novel doesn't capture my interest from the start or if the style of writing sort of bothers me. I try no to "drop" the book because this was someone's hard work and it deserves a chance, but sometimes I get plain fed up. The last book I really wanted to drop (but didn't) was Thief with no Shadow by Emily Gee. Didn't like it for many many reasons

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hey Sharry! I know the feeling. My temples start to feel tight and I completely agree about giving someone's blood, sweat, and tears the attention it deserves. I read your review of the Gee book. I hate it when a character's obsession gets so wearing you just want to die. Hope you have something good up next!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Great topic, Angie. I don't think I've read about bloggers discussing this before... but it is a topic all of us have some experience with.

    I usually plug through a book even if I'm not enjoying it so much for the same reasons as you. Very rarely do I never finish a book. My teen has no problem deciding halfway through a book that it's boring or what not and can put it down for good. She did that a few months ago when she was halfway through the fourth and final book in a series she was reading. A highly recommended one, too! I couldn't believe it and found myself strongly encouraging her to finish it. I backed off when she sighed and asked me if I was actually going to force her to finish it. (I admit I wanted so badly to say yes.)

    I almost envy that ability to just let a story go without knowing what happens even if I'm not enjoying it.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Christine, lol. Was this a series you had read and liked? I can see myself wanting to do the same thing in your place. I have trouble letting go unless I feel what I'm reading is an actual waste of my time. But I so rarely feel that way about reading. :)

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

You Might Also Like

Need by Carrie Jones

First of all. How about those gold lips? Shimmery! The color of those lips does a good job of representing the glittery-but-dangerous magic in this book. Just as the pale skin of their owner conveys the tone of the story quite well: pale, cold, and creepy. I'm pretty sure this is my first pixie urban fantasy and I wasn't sure what to expect. What I did not expect was feeling like I was back inside the world of  Stephen King 's  It . But apparently if a book's got Maine, winter, and a town with a curse on it, it will always evoke the same prickly, back-of-the-neck feelings in me. And  Need 's heroine shares my sentiments.  Zara's stepdad is dead. After watching her waste away day by day, Zara's mother puts her on a plane and sends her to her de facto grandmother--her stepdad's mom Betty. Betty lives in Maine. Maine feels like another world to Zara. A world in which the every surface is blanketed in snow and the local teenagers are all track stars or foot

Bibliocrack Review: Unsticky by Sarra Manning

I'm still just a little bit protective of my feelings over this book. Do you ever feel that way after finishing a book that completely threw you for a loop (in the very best way)? I feel distinctly protective of our relationship, the book and I. I'm still mulling over the way things ended on my lunch break and as I lie in bed waiting to fall asleep. Because it took me by such surprise, and because I fell in love with it so fast and hard, I'm just not at all sure I'm ready to talk about the experience. But enough of my book reviewing eccentricities. I've held onto my feelings long enough and it's time to let them see the light of day. Because Unsticky did a bit of a number on me. This is my first foray into Sarra Manning 's body of work and I'm kicking myself for waiting so long to find out for myself what the rest of you have been going on about. For those of you not familiar with her work, Ms. Manning is known for her contemporary young adult titles, w

Review: Shapeshifted by Cassie Alexander

I do not know how Cassie Alexander manages to serve up two installments in her wonderful Edie Spence series each year, but I am not one to look a gift horse in the mouth. Please to be continuing in this vein, Ms. Alexander! Because this series just gets better and better. And finishing Shapeshifted knowing I still have Deadshifted to look forward to at the end of this year just fills me with both gratitude and excitement. I worry about my favorite urban fantasy heroines. I worry. I am frequently forced to be away from them at times when I would really rather not leave. And when it comes to Edie, that was getting to be pretty much all the time. Her life was fairly decently fractured at the end of   the last book. I wasn't sure how she would cope with the enforced changes, and I wondered how long she would spend on the outside once things started up again in the new book. The questions that occupy my mind, you guys. You wouldn't know it to look at me, but it's a cacophon