Skip to main content

Ice by Sarah Beth Durst

As soon as I heard about Sarah Beth Durst's retelling of the East of the Sun, West of the Moon fairy tale, I felt that old familiar tug. I've read Edith Pattou's East and Jessica Day George's Sun and Moon, Ice and Snow and enjoyed parts of both of them very much, though neither captured my imagination the way I really wanted them to. You see, as it is basically a Norse version of Beauty and the Beast, I've always felt I ought to love this fairy tale more than I do. But I've been vaguely but persistently dissatisfied with every retelling I've read. I'm beginning to think this is a problem with the source material, a mismatch between us if you will, and not necessarily with the retellings themselves. As I've talked about before, it's a problematic storyline in many ways and particularly difficult to pull off in novel form, I think. Yet somehow I eagerly anticipate each new attempt, hoping this one will be the one.

Cassie loves ice. She was raised on it and has very little inkling of or interest in the world outside the Arctic research station that has been her home for the past eighteen years. As a little girl raised by her dedicated researcher father, she lived for those nights when her grandmother would tell her the story of her mother. Even though she knew it was only a fairy tale, Cassie never tired of the story of the rebellious daughter of the North Wind who defied her father and escaped an arranged marriage to the Polar Bear King to run away with her father, only to be blown away to the land of the trolls for her transgressions. To a little girl desperate for her mother, this story serves as a precious dream about what life would have been like if it had all gone well. But when she turns eighteen, Cassie's life changes. An ancient and enormous polar bear shows up and talks to her. He tells her her time is up and he is there to collect on his end of the bargain her mother made with the North Wind. He will have Cassie for his bride and carry her off to his ice palace. Being the smart cookie that she is, Cassie makes her own deal. If the bear rescues her mother from the trolls in that land east of the sun and west of the moon, she will marry him. The bear achieves the impossible and off they go.

The first half of this book is extremely strong and utterly enjoyable. I loved that Cassie had such a forceful personality, and I loved even more that Bear was allowed to be a vibrant character. In my past experience with this tale, so much of my problem with it seemed to stem from a lack of development of the bear's character and, therefore, a distinct lack of depth to the relationship between the girl and her intended. This was not a problem at all in the first half of Ice. Cassie is rugged and determined and smart with it. Bear is equally intent on achieving his goal and on his responsibilities as a munaqsri, or guardian of souls. This aspect of the world building was especially strong. I loved how unique it felt and the way Durst drew on Inuit legends and folklore felt very organic and fresh. As a result of these strengths, combined with the fact that she actually gave her leads time to get to know each other, I was immediately drawn to their developing relationship. It is sweet and slow and readable and just an all-around treat. One moment when Bear is in his human form standing behind Cassie as the two of them gaze out at the beauty of sunset over the frozen tundra actually had me catching my breath it was so lovely. At about the halfway mark, the bear is captured and it's up to Cassie to rescue him. This is normally the point where things get awesome in a story and I am 100 percent behind the heroine going in, guns a-blazin', and getting the job done. Unfortunately, everything slowed down just when it should have sped up. Bear is out of the equation and, unfortunately and rather surprisingly, Cassie doesn't hold the whole thing up on her own. She's traveling, traveling, traveling in the ice and snow and some things happen but never to their full potential. By the time she finally reaches the trolls I've lost interest in whether she'll win or not. The momentum and narrative thread are scattered in ten different directions and the final page in which things wrap up can't make up for the loss. Once again I'm filled with a sense of so much potential somehow unfulfilled. I truly loved the first half, but it drifted slowly downhill from there. And yet. I remain hopeful. Maybe the next one will be the one.

Comments

  1. Darn it! I was hoping you were going to say, "This is it! Go read this book right now!" I've had similar feelings around all retellings of Beauty and the Beast, East of the Sun, and Psyche and Cupid. That third is the one I set out to rewrite for my first novel, but I wasn't satisfied with my own retelling, either, so I shelved it. Maybe you're right that it's simply a problematic story. :(

    ReplyDelete
  2. Good review, I'm going to give this one a try. I enjoyed "East" and "Sun & Moon, Ice & Snow"...so it will be interesting to see Durst's take on things!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Such a shame you didn't get the buzz you were after from this one! It was my first experience of this tale and I was just so pleased with the setting and the non-passive heroine and the unfairness of Cassie being held against her will for her baby's best interest. I hope Durst has more books coming out soon, she seems to like the fairy tale stuff.

    ReplyDelete
  4. What timing! I just picked this one up at the library...
    Good to hear that even though it's not a rave review, it wasn't terrible.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I enjoyed this book, but had an issue with the abrupt ending. The cover of it is awesome! Polar Bears rule. Te-he!

    ReplyDelete
  6. It was a nawesome book even though the ending was like bam! Out of nowhere! I love it so much I am giving it away at my bog. If you want to check it out I will leave the link:

    http://catholickittie.blogspot.com/2009/11/ice-by-sarah-beth-durst-review.html

    ReplyDelete
  7. . I enjoyed "East" and "Sun & Moon, Ice & Snow"...so it will be interesting to see Durst's take on things!

    Work from home India

    ReplyDelete
  8. I really enjoyed the first half of Ice - particularly the bit when Cassie decides she must have an actual purpose rather than lying about like a limp dishrag (go her!). But I, too, felt like the adventure end of things was just missing something.

    I still really enjoyed reading it, though, not least because I'd never heard of East of the Sun, West of the Moon before!

    I've linked to your excellent review here.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hi, like the thoughtful review. For another Beauty and the Best retelling, if you haven't already read it, you could check out Juliet Marillier's HEART'S BLOOD, a fantasy set in ye olde Britain. The hero doesn't have to change from beast to animal physically, but the themes are really similar, and Ms Marillier said it was based on Beauty and the Beast. Not a brilliant story, but a good one, I thought - would be interested to hear your opinion!

    Anyway, I reviewed ICE a little while ago - wasn't a huge fan either, for much the same reason as you (although I didn't like the developing relationship as much - it seemed very sudden going from living together to having Bear's baby. I get that it wasn't actually sudden, a season passed in the book, but as a reader I didn't get any sense of that time passing).

    Anyway, thought I'd link to your review from mine, hope that's OK with you! Cheers :)

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Angie's Best Books of 2016

Let's just lay our cards on the table, shall we, and agree that, on the whole, 2016 was an abysmal year.
And I'd just like to personally invite it not to let the door hit it on the way out.
This is me being as charitable as I can possibly be at this point. 
That said, I want to send a glorious shout out to the wonderful books that have come out this past year, and to all the authors (and readers) who have not given in to the anxiety, depression, anger, and fear that I know so many of us have felt throughout the past twelve months (or more). It is the last day of the year, and I have poured all of my gratitude (and hope for a better one to come) into my annual list of my favorite reads of the year. Just 17 this year. Fewer than the past few years, which indicates a healthy dose of necessary rereading in this year that has been what it was, as well as the fact that I just didn't get to as many new releases.


(in the order in which I read them)
The Thirteenth Earlby Evelyn Pry…

My Year of Georgette Heyer | Book the First: The Convenient Marriage

This is not a drill. I repeat, THIS IS NOT A DRILL. I believe I am, in fact, upon the brink of accomplishing something that I have been meaning to do for years. I want you all to be the first to know that I just read my first very Georgette Heyer. That's right. I actually did it. After years of promising myself and countless others (many of you) that I would do it, I finally managed it! And I can tell that I'm about to dive headlong into a full-fledged binge.

After consulting all of your past comments on which Heyers are your favorites and why (and after some serious counsel from Beth and a well-timed trip to our local Barnes & Noble), I chose to start with The Convenient Marriage. I had no idea it would turn out to contain, without question, one of my favorite proposal scenes ever. The kind of proposal scene that makes you feel like nothing could ever go wrong after it. It takes place very early on, and it made me laugh and sigh repeatedly with delight. I know I will be …

Review | Hunted by Meagan Spooner

I'm just going to start off by saying I cannot stop thinking about this book. I finished it weeks ago, but this lovely Beauty and the Beast adaptation will not leave my mind. This is the first book I've really read by Meagan Spooner. I gave These Broken Stars a bit of a go awhile back, but we sort of drifted apart halfway through. Not the case here. The gorgeous cover caught my eye and the early glowing reviews reinforced my conviction. Having finished it, I immediately ran out and purchased copies for a number of the relevant readers in my life. And despite having pushed on and read several books since, Huntedis the one I find my mind and heart returning to over and over again.

Yeva holds a lot of things in. She loves her family—her father, her sisters—and so she sits obediently in the baronessa's chambers. She pretends to make small talk and embroider bits of cloth with the other ladies. She smiles politely at the young man who is said to be courting her (and doesn'…