This is my first book by Sara Zarr.
That's right. Before I picked up How to Save a Life, I had never read a Sara Zarr book.
Cue the echoing Silence of Judgement.
Okay, before you go off all half-cocked--I know. I know. It's just that everyone loves her. Like Sarah Dessen kind of love. And I was afraid I'd be disappointed (particularly as Sarah Dessen doesn't do much for me--I know, I know). So the hype got to me. I'm not proud of it, but there it is. And I'm not sure exactly what pushed me over this time around. All I can say is I saw this one pop up on NetGalley and just felt like it was time.
Jill doesn't recognize herself anymore. Ever since her father passed away eight months ago, it's been like this. She and her mother are existing in the same house, but that's about it. The crushing realization that he was the one thing connecting them weighs on Jill's soul, as day by day she grows more and more remote, driving away her friends, her boyfriend, and especially her mother. Then her mom hits her with the astounding news that she plans on adopting a baby. And not just that, but the teenage mom currently carrying said baby is on her way to stay with them for the duration of her pregnancy. And so Mandy enters their lives. Her past a big, vague gray, Mandy moves into the MacSweeney household and changes the frigid dynamic between Jill and her mother Robin in so many subtle ways. And while Robin fawns over Mandy, anxiously checking on her welfare, her comfort, her general happiness level, Jill suspects a snake in the grass. Determined to find out just exactly where Mandy comes from and why she doggedly insists on doing this open adoption her way, Jill sets out to protect her grief-blind mother from making the biggest mistake of their lives.
Jill is my kind of narrator. She's gruff on the outside, bit softer on the inside, and she would rather show anger than fear. And so she does. In spades. Those around her have to really care about her to stay. And when we meet Jill, there aren't so many of them left. Mandy is not normally my kind of narrator. She is ponderous in almost every way. Basically the polar opposite of Jill, Mandy wears long flowered dresses and "does" her hair every day. But she is also wonderful. Wonderfully awkward socially. As the narrative alternates between Jill and Mandy, I was able to get my fill of each girl. And I loved every minute of it. How well-rounded Sara Zarr's writing is, how smart the dialogue, how thoughtful the prose. Here's is one of my favorite examples, from Mandy's point of view (taken from my uncorrected ARC):
I don't want my daughter to ever hear a story or see a piece of paper or know that one exists on which I signed her away. I don't want her to ever think that I didn't want her. No matter what. I don't want to leave any evidence she could find later that she might think proves to her the worst things she thinks about herself on a bad day. Not when she's ten, not when she's fifteen, not when she's forty. Maybe I'll be there to explain it to her, but I can't know that sure enough right now to plan on it. I want it to feel like fate, the way she ended up with Robin. I want to be in her life like a good dream, like someone who might not always be there but who never really left. Her world should feel full of possibilities and open doors, not full of things that are closed and final.I mean, come on. How beautiful is that? And more than that, it's right. The writing rings with authenticity and feeling. My throat actually began to close up reading that passage, it felt so true. The excellent thing is, Ms. Zarr excels on several fronts. She is able to weave together the perfect blend of the profound and the light--such an important quality in contemporary literature, I think. Jill's relationship with her sometime (some would say long-suffering) boyfriend Dylan comes to mind. As does her friendship with Ravi--a boy from her high school who she reconnects with in a rather hilarious way. Because I can't resist, here is just a great passage early on between Jill and Dylan:
"I almost thought you weren't going to come. But I know you and winter and Tuesdays and pho."Brilliant. And just like that, it becomes impossible not to like both of them. Dylan for coming up with such an awesome system and Jill for understanding it. And him. I liked all the characters in this book. They were presented in 360, if you will. As a result I, as the reader, was afforded the opportunity to view them from all angles. And so I loved them. Because I knew them. You're so smart, Sara Zarr. Love is rock.
He shrugs. "What can I say? Pho is rock."
Dylan has this whole rating system for everything--food, bands, clothes, teachers, movies, cars, songs, life events--based on the game rock-paper-scissors. Whatever is the utmost in awesomeness, whatever is profoundly good, whatever is right and true, is rock. Because rock, though it can be beat (or "hidden," as Dylan prefers to say) by paper, can never be destroyed.
How to Save a Life is due out October 18th.
Hers for the Reading Review
Owl and Sparrow Review
Wear the Old Coat Review
I'm so glad you finally jumped into a Sara Zarr! I think she is just amazing, although I haven't yet read this one. But that's another good thing: there's another one for me to enjoy! Thanks for the review-alert!ReplyDelete
I really like the excerpts you chose! I've never read anything by Zarr but this looks like it might be a great place to start!ReplyDelete
Great review, Angie! This book was great and those excerpts are fantastic!ReplyDelete
This is the first Zarr book I've read too but I'll definitely be looking at others. (Sweethearts is currently on its way to me. :-p)
Thanks for the link by the way! Muh appreciated.
Ooh. Looks fun.ReplyDelete
I've never read anything by Sara Zarr and Sarah Dessen. LOL maybe I should change that with this book? It looks promising. Thanks for the heads up on NetGalley, I might try requesting this one there.ReplyDelete
Great review! I totally avoid things that are over-hyped, too, and tend to be the last one in on all things popular, haha. :) It's probably a good thing I discovered this book before the hype hit, or else I may have avoided it, too. So glad you liked it! Also, don't know if you linked to me on purpose or if it was automatically generated, but I wanted to say thanks either way! :)ReplyDelete
—Kayla (Owl & Sparrow)
So glad you got on the Zarr bandwagon! (But not one of those evil bandwagons your elementary school teachers always warned you about.) Dessen doesn't do much for me either, but Zarr is just so real and gritty and hopeful. My favorite line?ReplyDelete
“Mom and I, different as we are, are twin planets orbiting the same universe of grief but never quite making contact.”
Broke my freakin' heart.
Loved your review and not just because I love Sara Zarr's books. Which btw r just awesome. I am gonna wait till the book is available in India cos I don't want to read it on NetGalley but have the actual book with me :)ReplyDelete
I've never read anything by Sara Zarr either. I do love that last quote though.ReplyDelete
If it makes you feel better not only have I not read a book by her, I haven't heard of her before. Maybe one of these days, I'll see what it's all about.ReplyDelete
Confession myself. Had been waiting till the hype around Zarr had died down because I like to read books without forward expectations. My usual expectation of anything with hype secretly sucks. I proved myself right with Dances with Wolves and Titanic. Though I saw those during the hype. And was heartily rejected and argued with when I tried to make the point. Then.ReplyDelete
So I thought I'd learned. But your review of Zarr means I'll be putting her in my TBR pile. Because I just can't resist gritty and light.
Nice! I picked this one up at BEA. I really like Sara Zarr, but haven't read it yet. Your review makes me want to put it at the top of the TBR pile (after Daughter of Smoke and Bone, which is getting tons of great reviews). KarenSReplyDelete
Rhapsody, I know. I'm so pleased to have kicked it off this way. Which one would you recommend I read next?ReplyDelete
lisa, it certainly was for me.
Jo, you bet. I loved your review.
Liza, yeah, you'd enjoy this one, I think.
Chachic, I'd give it a go. It's quite good.
Kayla, my pleasure. Whenever I post a review, I go through and select other well-written reviews of the book to link to.
kathryn, ooh, such a good one. Love the women in this story.
Shweta, which one is your favorite so far?
carol, awesome, isn't it? I just loved the whole concept.
Ryan, lol, it does make me feel better actually.
Bets, I know exactly what you mean. But gritty and light is exactly what this one is.
Karen, I thought you liked her. I would bump it up. I'm currently in the middle of DoSaB. More to come on that...
Oh, your review has sold me on this when I read it the other day. I didn't love Sweethearts but I'm willing to try something else. Hopefully Netgalley approves me. :)ReplyDelete
oh i think you started with her absolute best. and you have reviews it so superbly :)ReplyDelete
Holly, I really think you'll enjoy this one. I haven't read SWEETHEARTS, but this one is just special.ReplyDelete
Nomes, yeah? Great to hear. And thanks! :)
I liked this one. A lot. But for me, it didn't have the same impact as Story of a Girl, although I liked all the characters (again, a lot!). It was perhaps just a wee bit predictable. That and Jill's Bronte rant kind of ruined it for me. She goes on about how everyone has to read Jane Eyre in HS, but that Anne is a more interesting Bronte than Emily. The passage kind of makes it sound like she thinks Emily Bronte wrote Jane Eyre... Picky, I know, but just those few sentences really threw me off.ReplyDelete