Skip to main content

Review: The Dream Thieves by Maggie Stiefvater

I figured I might as well go ahead and write this review while my stomach is still all twisted and jumpy from finishing it last night and being unable to settle down for hours afterward. Truthfully? I was so caught up I had to go pull my copy of The Raven Boys down off the shelf and reread my favorite bits to help me come down off the high of the second book. Honestly. I'm as bad as Ronan coming out of one of his dreams. Only I don't have a Gansey or a Noah to help harness me back to reality. So. You all will be my Gansey and my Noah, yes? Because I need you after the whirling dervish that was this book had its way with my emotions. It's not that I don't know what I'm getting into when I immerse myself in Maggie's latest book. It's that I'm utterly unable (and entirely uninterested) in distancing myself from these boys and this girl I love. And so when the gloves inevitably come off and the humor eases deceptively into anguish, I am left huddled in a fog of anxiety and murderous affection that lingers for days. Cue all you Ganseys and Noahs out there. Clearly, I could use that grounding right about now.

Mild spoilers for The Raven Boys follow.

Ronan has suspected a number of awful things for some time now. And whether he's aware of it or not, he's about to put several of those suspicions to the test. Up close and personal style. After Adam's unexpected and controversial activation of the ley line, things have been thorny between the boys and Blue. Yet the indefatigable Gansey soldiers on. And where Gansey goes, so goes Ronan. Or at least it's always been that way. Ever since Ronan moved into Monmouth Manufacturing and found a cause and a brother worth fighting for. But with the search for Glendower faltering up against the inexplicable whims of the ancient forest of Cabeswater, the onus of the quest shifts to Ronan's tattooed shoulders as he explores his strange new ability to form and snatch things from his dreams, bringing them back whole and perfect to the thick heat of Henrietta and Gansey's discerning eye. And while Ronan is tearing his way through the mists of a dream world he does not understand, Adam Parrish is stumbling along his own dark path. Unclear as to the status of his friendship with Blue and absolutely firm on his refusal to accept any help from Gansey, Adam's isolation increases even as his friends work to keep a hold on him. And underneath it all is Gansey's tireless thirst for the sleeping king and Blue's unchangeable fortune of true love and certain death.
Ronan Lynch lived with every sort of secret.
There is such a beautiful symmetry to this novel. And I don't mean just the lovely prologue and epilogue (though they are lovely and I do mean them). I also mean Ronan's and Adam's parallel journeys that nearly sent me into a state of collapse. I mean the space between Blue and Gansey growing thicker and more choked. And, most of all, I mean the unparalleled words. Maggie's writing always leaves me eyeing the other books on my nightstand askance. I'm afraid they'll peek inside the pages and see what they have to live up to. This time around, these particular words were used to sometimes devastating but always beautiful effect as they drove Ronan, Adam, Gansey, Blue, even Noah to the edge of their capacities. There were many painful and beautiful side effects, not the least of which was one truly spectacular kissing scene (not the one you're thinking of) and (perhaps more importantly) the development of my feelings for Gansey. Heretofore the boy has remained stubbornly distant in my mind, despite his open demeanor and infectious grin. To say nothing of his downright pivotal role in the whole cycle. As Ronan rather astutely notes:
There were many versions of Gansey, but this one had been rare since the introduction of Adam's taming presence. It was also Ronan's favorite. It was the opposite of Gansey's most public face, which was pure control enclosed in a paper-thin wrapper of academia. But this version of Gansey was Gansey the boy. This was the Gansey who bought the Camaro, the Gansey who asked Ronan to teach him to fight, the Gansey who contained every wild spark so that it wouldn't show up in other versions. Was it the shield beneath the lake that had unleashed it? Orla's orange bikini? The bashed-up remains of his rebuilt Henrietta and the fake IDs they'd returned to? Ronan didn't really care. All that mattered was that something had struck the match, and Gansey was burning.
I love this. I love that Gansey is finally burning. But more than that I love that it was Ronan's keen eye that allowed me to finally see Gansey. Because Ronan loves Gansey, I do, too. It was so deliciously dangerous being inside Ronan's head for the duration of this dark, dark book. Of course, this also made his pain mine. I gathered a few of my own suspicions regarding this most jagged of young men and the secrets he lives with. And I really don't know how I'm going to soldier on with these raven boys through all the nebulous, sharp-toothed things I fear are coming. But what I do know is that I will be there with them all at the end. As I remarked to my husband last night and to a friend of mine this morning, The Dream Thieves holds an eye-opening quantity of pain and gut-wrenching tension for just the second book in a quartet. Make no mistake, I am not complaining. But it does give a girl pause. At this rate, I will need the time in between installments to gear up for the second half. But as always in the intervening time, these precious few will never be far from my thoughts. Especially Adam. But then you probably knew that. If you're looking for a story worth living and breathing, The Dream Thieves will take you there.

The Dream Thieves is due out September 17th.

Buy

Linkage
Bunbury in the Stacks - "I loved The Dream Thieves unequivocally."
Nori's Closet - "This book is a pure, beautiful coming of age story."

Comments

  1. Anonymous8:34 AM

    Beautiful review, Angie! I can't wait to read it. Sounds even better than The Raven Boys. Would you rate it higher than The Scorpio Races? That's my favorite Maggie book.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Chachic! It flew out of me after finishing this doozy.

      I need to reread The Scorpio Races. It remains my favorite in my mind. A perfect book. But Maggie asked me in person if TSR was still my favorite after The Raven Boys and when I said yes, she assured me she'd get me by the end of this quartet! :)

      I do know that my emotions are fully engaged with this series. Fully.

      Delete
    2. Anonymous11:55 AM

      Oh my, what a promise! That's definitely something to look forward to. Your review is proof that the books get better as we move farther along the series. So yes, if Maggie keeps it up, the fourth one will knock The Scorpio Races off its pedestal.

      Delete
    3. Ah, the anticipation . . .

      Delete
  2. Anonymous10:40 AM

    Oh, thank you so much for sharing!! I'm listening to Raven Boys for maybe the third time now, and can't wait for this one. I'm dreaming of scraping together enough pennies to buy an autographed copy from Fountainhead Books.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm so glad you enjoyed it. Wouldn't it be awesome if you got one of the special art copies?!

      Delete
  3. Anonymous1:42 PM

    Oh, dear. I'm such a slow reader these days! Now I have Nowhere but Home, How I live Now and The Dream Thieves to get to quickly! I snagged an arc of this at BEA and keep grabbing it when I finish a book. But I've pre-ordered it also and I really want to read the hardcover first. KarenS

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Lol. Well, I don't mean to pressure you. And they really are all three lovely.

      I know what you mean about hardcovers being your first foray with the story and characters.

      Delete
  4. Anonymous3:02 PM

    Well... first of all, what a lovely and emotionally devastating review, Angie! If I was not already in love with these characters, I would be snatching up Raven Boys this instant. (Of course, your review for the Raven Boys was what made me absolutely certain I needed to read that one!) But methinks I am going to need a lot of emotional comfort when I finish this. Meanwhile, *huge hug* I'll be Noah.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh, thanks so much, Miss Clark. I loved your review on Goodreads, the stream of consciousness breakdown was awesome. I'm so happy you love these boys and Blue, too.

      I WILL BE THERE FOR YOU.

      P.S. *huge hug back* I needed that. :)

      Delete
  5. I KNOW, RIGHT??? I finished this, and channeled Donna: "THE WORDS! OH. MY. GOSH. THE WORDS." Amazing.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Total amazeballs, Melissa. I am not okay. In such a good way.

      Delete
  6. YES! I love that this book brought you finally around to Gansey and me finally around to Adam.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Talk about symmetry. Seems as though it's done its job nicely. :)

      Delete
  7. I am so beyond excited for this book. Can it be release day yet?! And you liked it better than The Scorpio Races?! AUGH now I'm dying of excitement.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You should be! This series just continues at such a high level. I wouldn't say better than TSR. That is a perfect book. But I am just as emotionally invested for sure.

      Delete
  8. Gorgeous review Angie. If I didn't already have it pre-ordered I'd be doing it now. I simply Can Not Wait to read this and you have made me even more anxious! A new Maggie book is the highlight of my reading year and I'm so sad she's not making it to the UK this time. I'd love to hear her talk about this one.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Alexa! You're so right. I realize her releases really are the highlight for me, too. What a wonderful thing that is. I'm still all jumpy over this one. Can't wait to hear what you think.

      Delete

Post a Comment

You Might Also Like

Need by Carrie Jones

First of all. How about those gold lips? Shimmery! The color of those lips does a good job of representing the glittery-but-dangerous magic in this book. Just as the pale skin of their owner conveys the tone of the story quite well: pale, cold, and creepy. I'm pretty sure this is my first pixie urban fantasy and I wasn't sure what to expect. What I did not expect was feeling like I was back inside the world of  Stephen King 's  It . But apparently if a book's got Maine, winter, and a town with a curse on it, it will always evoke the same prickly, back-of-the-neck feelings in me. And  Need 's heroine shares my sentiments.  Zara's stepdad is dead. After watching her waste away day by day, Zara's mother puts her on a plane and sends her to her de facto grandmother--her stepdad's mom Betty. Betty lives in Maine. Maine feels like another world to Zara. A world in which the every surface is blanketed in snow and the local teenagers are all track stars or foot

Bibliocrack Review: Unsticky by Sarra Manning

I'm still just a little bit protective of my feelings over this book. Do you ever feel that way after finishing a book that completely threw you for a loop (in the very best way)? I feel distinctly protective of our relationship, the book and I. I'm still mulling over the way things ended on my lunch break and as I lie in bed waiting to fall asleep. Because it took me by such surprise, and because I fell in love with it so fast and hard, I'm just not at all sure I'm ready to talk about the experience. But enough of my book reviewing eccentricities. I've held onto my feelings long enough and it's time to let them see the light of day. Because Unsticky did a bit of a number on me. This is my first foray into Sarra Manning 's body of work and I'm kicking myself for waiting so long to find out for myself what the rest of you have been going on about. For those of you not familiar with her work, Ms. Manning is known for her contemporary young adult titles, w

Angie's 2022 Must Be Mine

 Hopes, fears. We've got them in spades these days. Today, I'm choosing hope and delicious anticipation. And so here are my most anticipated titles of 2022: And no covers yet on these, but I'm looking forward to them just as much: The Unselected Journals of Emma M. Lion: Vol. 6 by Beth Brower You Were Made to be Mine by Julie Anne Long Heartbreaker by Sarah MacLean The Golden Enclaves by Naomi Novik Dreamer Trilogy, #3 by Maggie Stiefvater Cursed by Marissa Meyer Which titles are on your list?